western civilisation’s auto self destruct mechanism

I happened to catch a couple of minutes of a discussion on one of those right-wing news shows on Sky News last night. The subject was the Australian National University’s decision to ban a course on western civilisation. The fact that Australian universities are opposed to western civilisation is of course no surprise.

What caught my attention on this segment was the supposedly conservative female journalist’s passionate defence of western civilisation. Apparently western civilisation is awesome because it gave us feminism and LGBT rights.

The really depressing thing is that when you think about it she’s right. That’s pretty much what western civilisation has amounted to. The last three or four hundred years of western civilisation has been the story of the rise and triumph of liberalism. So what is destroying the West is in fact western civilisation.

We probably need to think a bit here about what we mean by western civilisation. In common usage it’s often assumed that it begins with classical Greece and encompasses European civilisation for roughly the past two-and-a-half thousand years.

I don’t think that’s a workable model. The classical Graeco-Roman civilisation, mediaeval European civilisation and the modern West seem to me to be so different as to constitute three separate civilisations. While the Renaissance is usually seen as the watershed between the mediaeval and modern worlds I think the key event was the Reformation. The Reformation shattered Christendom, not just as a reality but even as an ideal. It made the eventual triumph of secularism inevitable. The Reformation did not transform the mediaeval world – it destroyed it utterly.

The problem is that while the new civilisation that took the place of mediaeval society was bright and shiny and exciting there was a fatal flaw in the new operating system. It came with its own built-in auto self-destruct mechanism and no-one has ever been able to find a way to switch it off. It’s a dynamic civilisation but it’s doomed. It will fly high for quite a while and then suddenly explode in mid-air. That mid-air explosion is what we’ve been witnessing over the past few decades. Unfortunately it’s not the result of sabotage by nefarious external forces. It’s just inherent in the design that sooner or later it explodes.

Advertisements

3 comments on “western civilisation’s auto self destruct mechanism

  1. James Higham says:

    The really depressing thing is that when you think about it she’s right. That’s pretty much what western civilisation has amounted to.

    Really? Nothing else at all?

  2. Don't worry, it might turn out to be OK after all. When Rome collapsed, Byzantium appeared. Maybe it's going to be the same now.

  3. dfordoom says:

    Really? Nothing else at all?

    Perhaps I did phrase that in a clumsy fashion. My point is that the end point of western civilisation has been feminism and LGBT rights.

    And if you asked people today to name the greatest achievements of western civilisation I suspect that a depressing number would pick feminism and LGBT rights.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s